See how Sterling turned his love for cars into a thriving Shopify POD business using Printify and smart testing on TikTok.
Printify vs Bonfire
Compare how these two companies shape up
Printify vs Bonfire – see how both platforms compare on base costs, product quality, sales channels, and shipping before you start selling.
Here’s what people say about us
4.7
Based on 4000+ reviews on
Bonfire vs Printify: Which print-on-demand platform is best?
Both Bonfire and Printify help you sell products without inventory or upfront costs. Bonfire is a fundraising platform built around campaign pages, while Printify connects your own storefront to major eCommerce platforms. Here’s how their core features compare.
| Platform costs | ||
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Yes – $0/month, up to 5 stores | Yes – free campaigns and basic stores |
| Paid plan | Premium plan from $39/month, or $24.99/month billed yearly | Bonfire Pro: Essentials at $9.99/month or $99/year, Super at $299/year |
| Premium discount | Up to 20% off all products and up to 33% off new products | Lower base costs on the Super plan |
| Sample t-shirt base price | From $8.77 | $19.25 on Bonfire Pro Essentials |
| Print network | ||
| Print partners | 70+ Print Providers and 140+ print facilities | Centralized US production |
| Provider choice | Yes – choose manually or use Printify Choice | No |
| Local production | US, Canada, UK, EU, Australia, China, and more | US only |
| Average US delivery | 2-5 business days after production | 7-14 business days after a campaign ends |
| Business performance | ||
| Product catalog | 2,000+ products | 230+ products |
| Sales channel integrations | 10+, including Etsy, Shopify, Amazon, and eBay | None for eCommerce platforms – YouTube Merch Shelf and fundraising tools only |
| API access | Yes | No public API |
| Built-in storefront | Yes – Printify Pop-Up Store | Yes – campaign pages, stores, and Bonfire Pro |
| Customer support | ||
| Live chat and email | 24/7 merchant support | Contact form and email |
| Response time | 24/7 coverage | Typically 1-2 business days |
| Phone support | No | No |
| PrintifySign up for free | ||
Verdict: In the Printify vs Bonfire matchup, Printify wins on base cost, catalog size, and sales channels, so it’s the better fit for long-term brands. Bonfire is the better pick for short-term fundraising and campaign drops.
Switching to Printify is easy
Moving from Bonfire? Bring your designs over and keep more of every sale.
What to look for in print-on-demand platforms and services
The right POD platform protects your profit margins, offers high-quality products and consistent quality, connects to your sales channels, and gives you priority support when needed. Let’s compare Printify vs Bonfire on profitability, product selection, and integrations.
1. Profitability: Printify vs Bonfire
Base cost, shipping rates, and monthly fees decide how much you keep from each sale. For a fair Bonfire vs Printify comparison, we used Printify’s Free plan and Bonfire Pro Essentials. Campaigns print in batches, so they’re not a like-for-like match.
| Monthly subscription | $0 (Free plan) | $9.99 (Bonfire Pro Essentials) |
|---|---|---|
| Bella+Canvas 3001 price | $8.77 | $19.25 |
| Shipping fees (US) | $4.75 | $5.99 |
| Total cost (t-shirt and shipping) | $13.52 | $25.24 |
| Profit with a retail price of $25 | $11.48 | –$0.24 |
| Monthly profits from selling 30 t-shirts at a $25 retail price* | $344.40 | –$17.19 |
| Monthly profits from selling 100 t-shirts at a $25 retail price* | $1,148 | –$33.99 |
| PrintifySign up for free |
Verdict: Printify’s lower base cost leaves healthy margins, even for smaller sellers. On Bonfire, a $25 tee with free shipping loses money, so you’d have to charge buyers for shipping or raise your prices.
*Monthly profits are based on monthly subscription pricing and exclude taxes and sales channel fees.
2. Product selection: Printify vs Bonfire
A huge range of custom products and customization options lets you test niches and grow. Here’s how the catalogs stack up.
| Products in the catalog | 2,000+ | 230+ |
|---|---|---|
| Product categories | Apparel, accessories, home decor, drinkware, pet products, stationery, and more | Apparel, hats, bags, drinkware, home goods, and ornaments |
| Printing options | DTG, DTF, embroidery, all-over print, and more | Screen printing, patches, and engraving, among others |
| Branding options | Neck labels, packaging inserts, and more | Store branding with Bonfire Pro (logo, custom domain) |
| Eco-friendly range | Yes – eco-friendly products across apparel and home goods | Yes – eco-friendly blanks from brands like Stanley/Stella and Econscious |
Verdict: Printify’s catalog is almost nine times bigger, with all-over print apparel, home goods, and more printing options to test every new print idea. Bonfire covers the essentials with strong quality control and print quality, but far less variety.
3. Sales channel integration options: Printify vs Bonfire
Want to sell products where potential customers already shop? In the Bonfire vs Printify matchup, only Printify connects to major eCommerce platforms. Bonfire keeps sales on its campaign pages and integrated marketplace.
| Etsy | Included | Not included |
|---|---|---|
| Shopify | Included | Not included |
| TikTok Shop | Included | Not included |
| Amazon | Included | Not included |
| Squarespace | Included | Not included |
| Wix | Included | Not included |
| eBay | Included | Not included |
| PrestaShop | Included | Not included |
| WooCommerce | Included | Not included |
| Custom API integration | Included | Not included |
| Built-in storefront | Included | Included |
| PrintifySign up for free |
Verdict: With Printify, you can run a Shopify store, list on an existing marketplace like Etsy, and reach shoppers across social media channels – all from one dashboard. Bonfire works best when you have an existing audience to send to your campaign.
Why do sellers switch from Bonfire to Printify?
Bonfire is a great fit for fundraising campaigns and limited drops. Its unique features include built-in fundraising tools, and Bonfire will handle customer support for you. But for brand builders, lower base costs, a bigger catalog, and other sales channels make Printify the stronger print-on-demand platform. Each platform has its own pros.
Here’s what you get when you start selling with Printify.
Want to switch over, but you don’t have time?
Let us do the heavy lifting for you.
Switch to Printify today and get:
Listings migration
We’ll move your products over to Printify for you – enjoy better prices without lifting a finger.
Rebates
We’ll give you money back on sales when you transfer your products to us. Speak to our Team for more details.
Account manager
Our Expert Team provides dedicated guidance to print-on-demand businesses.
Never share sensitive information (credit card numbers, social security numbers, passwords) through this form.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply
Overview: Print-on-demand providers
How to start a print-on-demand business with Printify
Success stories from other merchants
From side hustles to six-figure brands, Printify merchants turn their ideas into thriving businesses. See how they did it.
Frequently asked questions about Printify vs Bonfire
Learn with Printify
Ready to build your print-on-demand empire?
Still weighing Printify vs Bonfire? If you want lower product costs, a bigger catalog, and the freedom to sell wherever your customers shop, Printify has you covered. Sign up for free, add your first design, and start selling today.
Comparison data for each company comes from public sources and was last updated on November 5, 2026. Prices and services may change. If you represent a company named here and spot outdated information, email [email protected].