Printify vs Gelato:
Compare how Print on Demand companies shape up
Successful eCommerce sellers choose Printify because it’s easy to use, offers the best profit margins, has 850+ top-quality products, and 24/7 customer service
Free to start - No Credit Card required
4.7 Based on 3000+ reviews on
and
Which Print-on-Demand Platform is Best?
The print-on-demand (POD) business model is one of the most popular in eCommerce. But which of the POD platforms should you choose? Sites like Printify and Gelato offer their own unique services, products, and integrations, keeping the market competitive, and making the decision tricky.
Platform Costs
Free Pricing Plan?
Most Expensive Subscription Cost
$29 p/m ($24.99 when paid annually)
gives access to 20% lower pricing on products.
Gelato+: $14.99/month or $139/year
gives access to shipping discount (no product discount)
Gold: $99/month or $999 a year
gives access to increased shipping discount
Print Network
Option to choose print provider?
Print Locations
USA, Canada, UK, EU, Australia, China
China, Mexico, Saudi Arabia, Japan, US, EU
Business Performance
Lowest Cost T-shirt
Shipping times to US
Products in Catalog
Branding Options
$5.67
2-5 days
850+
Neck Labels, Packaging Inserts
$8.14
2-7 days
100+
Neck Labels, Packaging Inserts (only available with subscription)
Customer Support
24/7 Chat?
Platform Costs
Free Pricing Plan?
Printify
Gelato
Subscription Costs
Printify
$29 p/m
($24.99 when paying annually)
Gelato
Gelato+: $14.99/month or $139/year
gives access to shipping discount (no product discount)
Gold: $99/month or $999 a year
gives access to increased shipping discount
Print Network
Option to choose print provider?
Printify
Gelato
Print Locations
Printify
USA, Canada, UK, EU, Australia, China
Gelato
China, Mexico, Saudi Arabia, Japan, US, EU
Business Performance
Lowest Cost T-shirt
Printify
$6.56
Gelato
$7.75
Shipping times to US
Printify
2-5 days
Gelato
2-7 days
Products in Catalog
Printify
850+
Gelato
100+
Branding Options
Printify
Neck Labels, Packaging Inserts
Gelato
Neck Labels, Packaging Inserts (only available with subscription)
Customer Support
24/7 Chat?
Printify
Gelato
What to look for in Print-On-Demand Platforms and Services
To succeed as an eCommerce store relying on a print-on-demand service, you need to assess each platform across various factors like ease of use, fulfillment locations, or product scope.
We’ve made this ultimate guide to POD platforms to help you make an informed decision for your business.
1. Profitability Printify vs Gelato
See how your profit can change from one POD company to another.
For your convenience, our t-shirt sales Profit Calculator outlines the potential sales of the most affordable t-shirt each company offers selling from a Shopify store to customers in San Francisco.
Monthly App cost
Bella & Canvas 3001 cost
Shipping cost for T-Shirt
Total cost (T-Shirt + Shipping)
Profit selling at $25
Monthly Profit selling 30 T-Shirts at $25
Monthly Profit selling 100 T-Shirts at $25
$0/29
$8.32
$4.75
$13.15
$11.49
$315.70
$1120.00
$0.00
$9.92
$4.66
$14.58
$10.42
$312.60
$1042.00
The data was collected in August 2023, so some information may have changed since.
Monthly App cost
Printify
$0/29
Gelato
$0.00
Bella & Canvas 3001 cost
Printify
$7.16
Gelato
9.92
Shopping cost for T-Shirt
Printify
$4.00
Gelato
$4.66
Total cost (T-Shirt + Shipping)
Printify
$11.16
Gelato
$14.58
Profit selling at $25
Printify
$13.84
Gelato
$10.42
Monthly Profit selling 30 T-Shirts at $25
Printify
$386.20
Gelato
$312.60
Monthly Profit selling 100 T-Shirts at $25
Printify
$1355.00
Gelato
$1042.00
2. Quality: Printify vs Gelato
The only way to get recurring customer and 5-star reviews is to sell high-quality products that customers love.
Check out what these top POD sellers say about Printify and Gelato Quality
Conclusion: Printify clearly comes out top when it comes to Price.
3. Print Coverage: Printify vs Gelato
The number of fulfillment centers a platfform has and their location will impact your average shipping time, shipping costs, and the carbon footprint of your business.
Print Locations
USA, Canada, UK, EU, Australia, China
China, Mexico, Saudi Arabia, Japan, US, EU
Product categories
Printify
USA, Canada, UK, EU, Australia, China
Gelato
China, Mexico, Saudi Arabia, Japan, US, EU
Where can I sell my custom t-shirts?
Our partner network delivers around the world, fast.
Conclusion: Both Printify and Gelato ship around the world and fulfill most of their orders locally.
4. Product Selection: Printify vs Gelato
Finding the right product for your customer is crucial. The higher the number of print-on-demand products a platform provides the better. The depth of a POD catalog, along with costs, shipping times, customization features, eco-friendly and branding options, will have a big say in the success of your business.
Products in catalog
Product categories
Branding options
Eco-friendly range
850+
Men’s Clothing, Women’s Clothing, Kid’s Clothing, Accessories, Home Decor, Shoes, Phone Cases, Mugs, Pet Supplies, Swimwear
Neck Labels, Packaging inserts
63 products
100+
Men’s Clothing, Women’s Clothing, Kid’s Clothing, Wall Art, Phone Cases, Mugs
Only for paying subscribers
16 products
Products in catalog
Printify
850+
Gelato
100+
Product categories
Printify
Men’s Clothing, Women’s Clothing, Kid’s Clothing, Accessories, Home Decor, Shoes, Phone Cases, Mugs, Pet Supplies, Swimwear
Gelato
Men’s Clothing, Women’s Clothing, Kid’s Clothing, Wall Art, Phone Cases, Mugs
Branding options
Printify
Neck Labels, Packaging inserts
Gelato
Only for paying subscribers
Eco-friendly range
Printify
63 products
Gelato
16 products
Conclusion: Printify has over eight times as many products to choose from. They also make it possible for anyone to add neck labels without a sbscription and have over ten times as many options when it comes to eco-friendly choices.
5. Sales Channel Integrations: Printify vs Gelato
Having a great product at an attractive price is no good if you haven’t got a way to sell. That’s why the best print-on-demand platforms integrate with world-famous sales channels and marketplaces.
Etsy
Shopify
Walmart
SquareSpace
WiX
eBay
More Etsy print-on-demand merchants choose Printify over other providers
4.4* – 1,928 Reviews
4.4* – 203 Reviews
Etsy
Printify
More Etsy print-on-demand merchants choose Printify over other providers
Gelato
Shopify
Printify
4.4* - 203 Reviews
Gelato
4.4* - 1,928 Reviews
Walmart
Printify
Gelato
SquareSpace
Printify
Gelato
WiX
Printify
Gelato
eBay
Printify
Gelato
Conclusion: Both Printify and Gelato integrate with major selling channels, but only Printify connects to Walmart and eBay. Printify has also collected more reviews from the Shopify appstore.
Check out all the Printify Integrations
Why switch to Printify?
Looking for sales margins, a vast selection of products, worldwide fulfillment locations, and the fastest delivery times around? Check out Printify.
Price
Printify is proud to have some of the lowest prices in the industry - we check them regularly - allowing you to make a higher margin on every sale.
Selection
With 850+ products in the Printify catalog, you're sure to find bestsellers, whatever your audience
Learning Resources
Our Help Center, Blog, and YouTube channel are crammed full of the info you need to succeed.
Quality
Our Print Providers have to comply with our extensive quality standards.
Printify Premium
Printify is always free to use, but upgrade to the Printify Premium plan and you'll get a 20% discount on all products.
Easy to use
Printify's simple software makes it simple to add your designs to beautiful products in minutes.
Speed
With Printify order routing enabled, your customer orders go to the nearest print provider - shortening both production and delivery times while reducing shipping costs.
24/7 Support
Whatever concerns you may have, our merchant support team is here to help. Providing guidance, assistance, advice, and support via chat and email 24/7. And our Help Center, Blog, and YouTube channel provide useful information and tips on all related topics.
Bulk Order Discounts
Order in bulk and get up to a 30% discount on shipping. A great option for brick-and-mortar stores, events, and other occasions.
Want to switch over but you don't have time?
Let our team do the heavy lifting for you.
Switch to Printify today and get:
Listings migration
We'll move your products over to Printify for you. Meaning you get to enjoy better prices without lifting a finger.
Rebates
We'll give you money back on sales you make on products you move to us. Speak to the Team for more details.
Account Manager
Get dedicated assistance from our Expert team.
Company Overviews
Printify is the world’s most famous print-on-demand platform HQ’d in San Francisco, USA, founded in 2015. It offers 850+ white-label products in categories like clothing, accessories, and home decor. Printify has 100+ order fulfillment facilities worldwide and ships millions of packages every month.
Gooten is a print-on-demand fulfillment company from the USA, founded in 2012. It offers 150+ clothing, accessories, and home & living products from 45+ fulfillment facilities around the world.
Gelato is a print-on-demand company based out of Norway. It was founded in 2012 and has operation in 32 countries. It’s also the name of a popular Italian ice cream.
Printful is a print-on-demand fulfillment company from Riga, Latvia, founded in 2013. It has 10 fulfillment facilities around the world and 350+ white-label products in categories like clothing, accessories, and home & living.
Teelaunch is a print-on-demand company based in the USA and founded in 2014. It offers 120+ clothing, accessories, and home decor products. Teelaunch has 18 fulfillment facilities in Canada, the US, Australia, Spain, and the UK.
Moteefe is a print-on-demand fulfillment company from London, UK, founded in 2014. Moteefe offers 50+ products in categories like clothing, accessories, and home & living. The company has 25 order fulfillment facilities worldwide.
Gearbubble is a print-on-demand fulfillment company from the USA, founded in 2014. It offers 30+ products in the clothing, accessories, and home & living categories and has 7 fulfillment facilities in the US, Germany, and the UK.
CustomCat is a print-on-demand fulfillment company from the USA, that was founded in 2015. It offers more than 300 customizable white-label products in multiple categories, such as clothing, accessories, and home & living.
How to Start a Print on Demand Business with Printify
All it takes is five simple steps.
Step 1
Sign up for Printify
Create your account to start adding your designs to our blank backpacks for free.
Step 2
Choose your product
Head over to the Printify Product Catalog and choose the bag(s) that works for you.
Step 3
Add your design
Upload an existing design or design one directly in our Mockup Generator.
Step 4
Publish to your store
When you’re happy, connect your Printify account to your Etsy, Shopify, Walmart, or other store, and click Publish.
Step 5
Sit back and profit
We’ll take it from here. Every time a customer makes a purchase, we’ll print, package, and ship it, fast. You just collect the profits.
Printify Changed my Life
Printify is all about helping anyone, anywhere unlock their own personal freedom by making it possible to start selling top-quality merchandise online. So we love to tell stories of how we’ve helped people do just that.
Canadian Jay De Souza is a well-known POD heavyweight, who went from a stressful bank job to multiple Etsy and Amazon stores with over $2.5 million in sales.
Christina has cracked the code to make more way past Halloween, Black Friday and Christmas. Sell more after the holidays using her quick and easy tips.
Terra tells us how Puddin Threads found their design style that earned $60000, after 6 months of trying.
Ready to Start Your Print-On-Demand Business?
The information provided on this page, including any comparison of services and prices, is based on data that has been obtained from publicly accessible sources associated with the companies mentioned. The data was last updated on July 21st 2023.
While we strive to provide accurate and timely information, we make no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability of the information contained in this article for any purpose. The use of this information and any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk. We understand that the information may change over time and therefore may become outdated or may not accurately represent the current services and prices offered by the companies mentioned.
If you are a representative of one of the companies mentioned in this article and believe any information is inaccurate or outdated, we invite you to contact us at [email protected] to provide updated information. We are committed to promptly updating any information found to be inaccurate.