Meet Catherine Waites, Who Turned Everyday Crafting into a Success Story
Here’s a print-on-demand success story rooted in handmade beginnings, gradual scaling, and a streamlined workflow supported by Printify fulfillment.
Printify vs Gelato
Compare popular print-on-demand services for creating and selling products worldwide
Printify beats Gelato on price and catalog size. T-shirts start at $6.66 compared to Gelato's $8.61. The Printify Catalog has over 2,000 products, compared to Gelato's 400+, and Printify lets merchants choose their own Print Provider for every order.
Free to start – No credit card required
Here’s what people say about us
4.7
Based on 4000+ reviews on
Which is better, Printify or Gelato?
Platform costs
Free plan
Unlimited product uploads, up to five online stores
Full catalog access, two store integrations
Premium discount
Up to 33% off product costs
Up to 25% off product prices
Sample t-shirt base price
$6.66 Standard, $4.92 Premium
$8.61
Print network
Provider choice
Merchants can select a specific Print Provider per product
Orders route automatically to the nearest partner
Local production
Facility-by-facility selection for price, location, and quality
About 90% of orders are produced locally
Average US delivery
2 to 8 business days
3 to 6 days
Business performance
Product catalog
2,000+ products, including apparel, wall art, phone cases, and home decor
400+ products
Sales channel integrations
10+ platforms, including Shopify, Etsy, Amazon, eBay, and TikTok Shop
6 major eCommerce platforms
API access
Yes, for custom integrations
Yes, for custom setups
Free Pop-Up Store
Yes
No
Customer support
Live chat and email
24/7
24/7
Response times
Fast, per merchant reviews
Slower during off-hours, per user reports
Phone support
Not available
Not available
Verdict: Printify offers more value for your money than Gelato, with a larger Catalog, lower base prices, and a Premium plan that cuts product costs by up to 33%.
Easily switch to Printify
Easily switch to Printify
Scale your print-on-demand business and access the largest product Catalog in the industry at lower prices. See exactly how to switch from Gelato to Printify step by step.
How to choose the right print-on-demand platform
Compare print providers on price, ease of use, fulfillment locations, print quality, and product selection. Read our full guide on Gelato and Printify to see which platform fits your business goals.
1. Profitability
See how profit margins shift between print-on-demand companies. Our t-shirt Profit Calculator compares Gelato and Printify's cheapest t-shirts for a Shopify order shipped to San Francisco.
Monthly subscription
$39/month ($24.99/month billed yearly)
$29.99/month ($19.99/month billed yearly)
Bella + Canvas 3001 price
$11.29
$16.83
Shipping fees (US)
$4.95
$4.99
Total cost (t-shirt and shipping)
$21.82
$15.68
Profit with a retail price of $25
$8.76
$3.18
Monthly profits from selling 30 t-shirts at a $25 retail price*
$223.80
$65.41
Monthly profits from selling 100 t-shirts at a $25 retail price*
$837.00
$288.01
This data was collected in September 2026.
*Monthly profits are based on monthly subscription pricing and exclude taxes and sales channel fees.
Where do Printify and Gelato print and ship from?
Our partner network delivers around the world, fast. Printify runs 1140+ print facilities, and Gelato operates across 32 countries, so both platforms can produce orders close to the buyer.
Printify also lets merchants pick a Print Provider for each high-quality product, balancing price, location, and quality on their own terms. In the most recent tracking period, 92% of Printify orders shipped from a facility in the same region as the customer, resulting in faster delivery times and eliminating unnecessary long-distance shipping.
2. Product selection
Both Gelato and Printify offer eco-friendly product lines, and Printify adds digital printing methods that use 90% to 95% less water than traditional garment printing. Neck labels and branded stickers are available on Printify without a subscription; Gelato reserves branded labels and custom packaging inserts for select products under Gelato+.
Products in catalog
2,000
400+
Product categories
Men's clothing, women's clothing, kids' clothing, accessories, and home and living
Apparel, wall art, mugs, photobooks, cards, calendars, stationery and business, and tote bags
Branding options
Branded neck labels, packaging inserts, gift messages
Branded labels, packaging inserts
Eco-friendly range
90+
40+
Verdict: Printify’s Catalog is much larger than Gelato’s and contains more niche and premium products, making it the better choice for stores that want to stand out with unique items.
3. Sales channel integrations
Competitive pricing and consistent product quality only convert into profit when a store reaches buyers across various sales channels.
Printify integrates with 10+ eCommerce platforms; Gelato connects to six.
Etsy
Yes
Yes
Shopify
Yes
Yes
Amazon
Yes
Yes
Squarespace
Yes
Yes
BigCommerce
Yes
Yes
Wix
Yes
Yes
eBay
Yes
Yes, via Order Desk
Prestashop
Yes
No
WooCommerce
Yes
Yes
TikTok Shop
Yes
Yes (TikTok Shop US and UK only)
Custom API integration
Yes
Yes
Verdict: Printify connects to more sales channels than Gelato, including eBay. Merchants can also launch a free Pop-Up Store with a unique link and start selling within minutes, at no extra cost.
Why sellers switch from Gelato to Printify
- Lower base prices, with t-shirts starting at $6.66 against $8.61 with Gelato (September 2026)
- Over 2,000 products from a global network of Print Providers
- US delivery in two to eight business days, against three to six business days with Gelato
- Full control over retail prices, on top of lower base costs
Higher profit margins
Printify’s competitive base prices, Premium plan discounts, and choice of Print Providers make it possible for sellers to keep more profit from each sale.
Largest product selection
The Printify Catalog holds over 2,000 products, backed by 140+ print facilities, so merchants can find their next bestseller without juggling multiple platforms.
Earn and learn
Our Help Center, blog, and YouTube channel have all the valuable insights you need to succeed with your POD store.
Offer your customers the best quality
Our Print Providers comply with extensive quality standards to provide top-notch global fulfillment.
Printify Premium
Printify is free to use, but upgrade to Printify Premium to access an additional 33% discount on our Catalog.
Easy design tools
Use our free and beginner-friendly Product Creator to design custom products in minutes.
Offer shorter delivery times
Our Order Routing feature ensures your customer orders go to the nearest Print Provider to their address, reducing delivery times and costs.
24/7 support
Our expert Support Team is ready to help around the clock with any of your print-on-demand questions.
Save more with bulk order discounts
Order 20 or more of the same product from one Print Provider and save up to 46% on products and 50% on shipping costs with our bulk discount.
Want to switch over, but you don’t have time?
Let our team do the heavy lifting for you. Switch to Printify today and get:
Listings migration
We move your products to Printify for you, so you get better prices without lifting a finger.
Rebates
Get money back on sales when you transfer your products to us. Speak to our team for details.
Account manager
Our expert team provides dedicated guidance to print-on-demand businesses.
Never share sensitive information (credit card numbers, social security numbers, passwords) through this form.
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply
Overview: Print-on-demand providers
Printify is the world's most famous print-on-demand platform, headquartered in San Francisco and founded in 2015. It offers 2,000+ products in categories like clothing, accessories, and home decor, ships from 140+ order fulfillment facilities worldwide, and delivers millions of packages every month.
Gelato is a print-on-demand company based in Norway. Founded in 2012, it operates in 32 countries. It's also the name of a popular Italian ice cream.
Gooten is a print-on-demand fulfillment company with more than 500 clothing, accessories, and home and living products from over 110 fulfillment facilities worldwide.
Printful is a print-on-demand fulfillment company with 19 fulfillment facilities around the world and over 540 products in categories like clothing, accessories, and home and living. It’s also Printify’s sister company.
Teelaunch is a print-on-demand company based in the USA, founded in 2014. It offers 120+ clothing, accessories, and home decor products across 18 fulfillment facilities in Canada, the US, Australia, Spain, and the UK.
CustomCat is a print-on-demand fulfillment company from the USA, founded in 2015. It offers more than 300 customizable white-label products across categories like clothing, accessories, and home and living.
Teemill is a UK-based eco-friendly POD platform built around organic materials and sustainable manufacturing practices.
Tapstitch specializes in fashion-forward apparel with eco-friendly, premium blanks and large print areas.
Prodigi is a UK-based POD service specializing in fine art, photography, and wall art printing.
Redbubble is a marketplace-style POD platform. Redbubble vs Printify comparisons often highlight marketplace reach against independent brand control.
Bonfire is a print-on-demand platform built for fundraising campaigns and simple merch stores.
How to start a print-on-demand business with Printify
Access all the tools you need to sell custom products in just five simple steps.
“Printify changed my life”
Printify is all about helping anyone, anywhere, unlock their own personal freedom by selling top-quality merch online, and we love sharing stories of their massive success.
Printify vs Gelato: Frequently asked questions
The information provided on this page, including any comparison of services and prices, is based on data that has been obtained from publicly accessible sources associated with the companies mentioned. The data was last updated on September, 2026.
While we strive to provide accurate and timely information, we make no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability of the information contained in this article for any purpose. The use of this information and any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk. We understand that the information may change over time and therefore may become outdated or may not accurately represent the current services and prices offered by the companies mentioned.
If you are a representative of one of the companies mentioned in this article and believe any information is inaccurate or outdated, we invite you to contact us at [email protected] to provide updated information. We are committed to promptly updating any information found to be inaccurate.
