How to Become an Etsy Star Seller in 2024

How to Become an Etsy Star Seller in 2024

The Etsy Star Seller program offers a unique opportunity for many Etsy sellers to distinguish themselves in this increasingly competitive and saturated online marketplace. 

Whether you’re a seasoned Etsy seller with a range of print-on-demand goodies or just starting out with some handmade products, aiming for the Star Seller status could give your Etsy shop the boost it needs.

In this guide, we’ll provide you with everything you need to become a Star Seller on Etsy in 2024 – and beyond.

Let's Find Out What a Star Seller Is

A smiling woman with glasses working on her laptop and taking notes.

This status, reflected by a Star Seller badge on their shop and listings, is a testament to their dedication to maintaining a high-quality shopping experience for Etsy buyers.

Etsy Star Sellers 

  • provide outstanding customer service, 
  • have excellent ratings, 
  • promptly fulfill orders, 
  • and meet a minimum sales threshold.

The Star Seller program is Etsy’s way of recognizing and rewarding these top-notch sellers who go above and beyond for their customers.

Getting the Etsy Star Seller Badge: Essential Criteria and Requirements

To secure the sought-after Star Seller badge, Etsy sellers must meet important criteria spanning various aspects of their online business. 

Etsy Star Seller requirements include impeccable customer service, high ratings, timely shipping, and more regarding the seller’s performance, all integral to a successful Etsy business. 

Understanding and meeting the Star Seller evaluation criteria is essential for sellers aiming to achieve this recognition. Let’s look at the criteria in more detail.

Great Customer Service

Delivering great customer service involves prompt responses to customer inquiries and concerns. 

To qualify as a Star Seller, Etsy vendors must respond quickly to the first message from customers. This means responding within 24 hours, at least 95% of the time, so maintaining a high message response rate should be your top priority. 

This guarantees you communicate promptly and effectively, contributing to a positive customer experience.

Tips for Success:

Enable an auto-reply function for initial messages to make sure you respond within the required timeframe, even when you can't answer immediately. Tools like HelpScout or Zendesk can help manage customer messages more efficiently.

Excellent Ratings

Star Sellers are expected to maintain a minimum average review score of 4.8 for the review period. 

This score reflects their commitment to offering high-quality products and outstanding customer service. Accumulating positive reviews from customers not only builds your reputation but contributes to your success.

Tips for Success:

Encourage your buyers to leave reviews and always strive to exceed their expectations. Check out the Etsy Seller Handbook on How to Get 5-Star Reviews for more insights.

Timely Shipping and Tracking

Star Sellers must have on-time shipping for at least 95% of their orders. This means that the shipping label should be purchased and marked as dispatched on Etsy before or on the dispatch date stated in the listing description.

Tips for Success:

Stay organized and keep an accurate inventory to make sure you can fulfill orders promptly. Use Etsy's Shop Manager to keep track of your orders and shipping deadlines.

At Least Five Sales Worth $300

To qualify, sellers must make at least five sales amounting to $300 or more during the evaluation period. This minimum sales requirement guarantees that the Star Seller status is awarded to active, successful sellers on Etsy’s platform.

Tips for Success:

Optimize your listings for Etsy search and promote your shop on social media to attract more customers.

Make It Happen Today!

How Often and for What Time Period Are Etsy Sellers Evaluated?

To become a Star Seller, every aspect of your Etsy business, including message response rate, order fulfillment, shipping, and reviews, is scrutinized over a rolling 90-day period. 

For instance, if the current review period is August, your seller performance from May 1st to July 31st comes under the scanner. 

This rolling evaluation process helps guarantee that all sellers on the Etsy platform, whether they’re into handmade business, sell digital products, or offer shipping of physical items, consistently deliver an optimal shopping experience and keep the Etsy customers happy.

Tracking Your Progress on the Path to Becoming an Etsy Star Seller

Keeping track of your progress on the path to receiving a Star Seller badge on Etsy is simplified through your Seller Dashboard, accessible via your Shop Manager in both the Etsy app and website. This essential tool offers a wealth of information and provides specific details about your Etsy shop’s performance across the various Star Seller criteria categories. 

Whether it’s your message response rate, the number of sales, your on-time shipping status, or the quality of customer service you provide, you can find it all on this dashboard. 

With this shop data, Etsy sellers can better strategize and improve their seller performance, enhancing their chances of obtaining that desired Etsy Star Seller badge. It’s an essential resource for any Etsy seller serious about advancing their business and reaching for the stars.

Tips for Success:

Regularly reviewing your Seller Dashboard allows you to identify areas of improvement promptly and make adjustments to your customer service, response times, or shipping processes, enhancing your journey to Star Seller status.

The Benefits of Being an Etsy Star Seller

A woman sitting on a couch and looking at her laptop screen.

Achieving the Star Seller badge unlocks significant benefits designed to supercharge your Etsy business. This desired badge doesn’t just symbolize excellence, it propels your shop onto a new playing field and builds trust among Etsy shoppers.

Stand Out Among Other Sellers

The Star Seller badge is a digital spotlight, illuminating your shop in a crowded Etsy marketplace. This badge signals to potential buyers that your shop prioritizes quality, on-time dispatch, message response rate, and customer service. It sets you apart from competitors and enhances your appeal to discerning shoppers.

More Chances to Be Featured by Etsy

With the Star Seller badge, you can increase the odds of your products getting featured in Etsy’s promotional materials, email campaigns, and social media posts. This visibility boost can drive more traffic to your shop, raising the potential for increased sales.

Gain More Traffic and Sales

Trust is a crucial currency in eCommerce, and the Star Seller badge is like a seal of trust on your Etsy store. This badge demonstrates a proven track record of excellent customer service, which can attract more traffic and encourage shoppers to choose your shop over others, leading to increased sales.

Start your Etsy print on demand business today!

How to Become an Etsy Seller With Print On Demand?

A man and a woman in an office, looking at a laptop screen and smiling.

As more entrepreneurs embrace the world of eCommerce, Print on Demand has emerged as a powerful strategy for Etsy sellers. Let’s explore a detailed roadmap to establishing print-on-demand Etsy shops that ooze success.

Create Your Etsy Shop

The first step to becoming a star Etsy seller is creating your Etsy store. Choose a distinctive shop name that mirrors your brand identity, design your shop to reflect your brand ethos, and establish secure payment and shipping options. Your shop will be the bedrock of your Etsy store, so spend time crafting an appealing and user-friendly space.

Sign Up for Printify

To streamline your print-on-demand process, register for a Printify account. As a third-party print-on-demand service, Printify simplifies your operations by taking care of your products’ printing, packaging, and shipping. This leaves you ample time to sell items and focus on the other pillars of your business, like marketing strategy and delivering top-notch customer service.

Connect Etsy to Printify

After setting up your accounts, it’s time to integrate your Etsy store with Printify – our one-click integrations make this step a breeze. You’ll be able to effortlessly upload your unique designs, select the products they’ll adorn, and directly list them in your Etsy shop. This seamless integration optimizes your listing process, saving valuable time.

Create Custom Products

Printify’s easy-to-use design tool, the Mockup Generator, is your canvas to create custom products that resonate with your target audience. Whether you envision your designs on t-shirts, coffee mugs, art prints, or more, the Printify Catalog allows you to transform a wide array of over 900 products into unique pieces of art – all without needing to manage any physical inventory.

Pro tip

Consider adding custom branding, such as a packaging inserts or shipping label, to make all the reviews you receive even more wonderful.

Publish and Start Selling

With your one-of-a-kind products designed and listed, it’s time to hit Publish and open your Etsy store to the world. After publishing your custom products, you’ll be on your way to making your first sale on Etsy. Embrace your entrepreneurial spirit, engage with the Etsy community, and start your journey towards becoming an Etsy Star Seller.

Etsy Star Seller Program FAQs

Etsy sellers can earn badges by meeting specific criteria outlined in the Star Seller program. Besides the prestigious Star Seller badge, there are other badges, such as the Best Seller badge, Smooth Shipping, Rave Reviews, or Speedy Replies badges, each demonstrating a seller’s excellence in different areas.

While becoming a Star Seller can increase your visibility and trustworthiness, Etsy has stated that the badge doesn’t directly affect a shop’s search ranking in Etsy search results.

Star Seller badges can be removed if a seller falls short of the program’s criteria during a review period, for example, a delayed response after a shopper’s initial message. For detailed information, refer to Etsy’s Star Seller Badge Removal Policy.

If your Star Seller badge was removed, it may be because your performance didn’t meet the criteria during the last review period. To regain your badge, focus on improving customer service, shipping times, and receiving positive reviews.

Going into vacation mode doesn’t affect your status as long as you meet all the criteria during the review periods when your shop is active.

When you become a Star Seller, the badge you receive is a tangible way of demonstrating your dedication to providing unparalleled customer service, like speedy message response, quality products, and timely shipping. By striving for this recognition, you can boost your Etsy business’s credibility, visibility, and success in 2023 and beyond.

Etsy communicates your Star Seller performance through the Seller Dashboard in your Shop Manager. It provides detailed metrics about your performance for each Star Seller criteria category.

Etsy provides various tools and resources to help you strive for the Star Seller badge. These include the Seller Handbook, detailed performance metrics, and good customer service features like auto-reply to buyer messages.

Maintaining your Star Seller status requires consistently meeting the qualification criteria. Keep providing excellent customer service, responding promptly to messages, shipping orders on time, and encouraging buyers to leave reviews. On-time shipping means that you’re meeting the delivery estimates provided to customers.

Make It Happen Today!

Share the article



Write a comment