Create a shirt with Printify today
Is DTF the same as screen printing? Not quite. These two printing methods may both put ink on fabric, but they go about it in totally different ways. If you need vibrant colors, durable prints, or a cost-effective production method, understanding the key differences will help you choose the best option for your garment decoration needs.
In this ultimate DTF vs screen printing showdown, we’ll compare everything – setup costs, print quality, production speed, and more – so you can pick the perfect printing technique for your business.
Key takeaways
- DTF and screen printing are both top-tier printing methods, each excelling in different areas.
- DTF involves printing on a film transfer, while screen printing requires individual screens for each color.
- DTF transfers create soft, full-color prints on any fabric without setup headaches.
- Screen printing excels at bold, high-volume designs with a slightly textured finish.
- DTF offers lower setup costs, making it perfect for small orders or one-offs.
- Screen printing is more cost-effective in large batches due to bulk production efficiency.
- Printify makes selling DTF products easy – sign up, design, and start selling today.
What is DTF printing?
Imagine printing a sticker, but instead of slapping it on your laptop, you press it onto a t-shirt – boom, that’s DTF (direct-to-film) printing.
This digital printing process takes your design, prints it onto a special film, sprinkles it with adhesive powder (like magic dust), and then fuses it onto fabric using a heat press. No separate screens, no hassle.
DTF printing has lower setup costs, making it a budget-friendly choice for vibrant colors, intricate designs, and durable prints that withstand repeated washes. It’s perfect for dark and textured fabrics, plus it works on a variety of other materials.
What is screen printing?
Screen printing is like making a fancy stencil, then flooding it with ink – one color at a time. Each color in your design needs its own screen, meaning more setup time and equipment.
But here’s the payoff: screen printing delivers bold, vibrant prints that last. It’s a tried-and-true printing method that’s been around forever. While higher startup costs make it better for bulk orders, it’s a solid choice for multi-color designs with a classic, textured feel.
What’s the difference between DTF and screen printing?
DTF and screen printing both create high-quality prints, but they do so in very different ways. DTF is a digital process that’s flexible, fast, and great for complex designs, while traditional screen printing uses wet ink and separate screens to create bold, durable prints.
Which one should you choose for your custom designs? Let’s break it down.
| DTF | Screen printing | |
|---|---|---|
| Quality | High-quality prints with precise details and vibrant colors. | Screen printing excels at bold prints with a textured feel. |
| Durability | Holds up well to repeated washing but may feel slightly different on fabric. | Super durable and lasts many washes without fading. |
| Complexity of designs | Handles multi-color designs and intricate details with ease. | Best for bold, simple designs; multiple colors require different screens. |
| Fabric type | Works on cotton, polyester, blends, leather, and even textured fabrics. | Best for cotton and cotton blends; other fabrics may need extra prep. |
| Sustainability | Uses less water and lower setup costs, but relies on special film and adhesives. | Uses wet ink, requires more equipment and setup, but less plastic waste. |
| Minimum order | No minimums. Print one or print a hundred. | High setup costs mean it’s best for bulk orders. |
| Production time | Fast production speeds, great for quick print jobs. | Takes longer due to setup time and screen preparation. |
| Average cost | Cost-effective for small runs; lower upfront costs. | High setup costs, but cheaper per piece in large batches. |
Now that we’ve covered the basics, let’s take a closer look at each point and see which printing technique is right for you.
Quality
DTF printing is like a high-definition TV for your designs – sharp details, vibrant tones, and full-color prints that pop on light and dark fabrics alike. Perfect for complex or photo-like designs.
Traditional screen printing is all about bold, rich colors and that slightly textured, ink-saturated feel. While it can’t always match the sharp details of DTF printing, screen printing shines at producing vibrant, high-quality prints with a premium look and feel.
Durability
DTF prints are tough cookies – they can survive repeated washing without cracking or fading, but they do have a different texture than screen print transfers. Since the ink sits on top of the fabric, you might notice a slightly rubbery feel.
If DTF printing is durable, screen printing is rock solid. Since the ink is absorbed into the fabric, screen prints won’t crack, peel, or fade for ages. That’s why screen printing is perfect for team jerseys, work uniforms, and merch that needs to withstand endless washes.
Complexity of designs
DTF is your go-to for intricate, full-color images. Since it’s a digital process, you can print multi-color designs, fine gradients, and detailed prints without worrying about screens or color limitations. Want to print a full-color galaxy scene on a t-shirt? No problem – DTF’s got you covered.
Screen printing, while renowned for producing vibrant, high-quality prints, has a catch: each color requires a separate screen. This makes complex designs trickier and multi-color designs more expensive. But for bold logos, typography, and simple graphics, screen printing is unmatched.
Sustainability
DTF uses less water than screen printing and doesn’t require the chemical-heavy screen preparation process. However, it does involve special film and adhesives, which means it’s not completely waste-free.
Traditional screen printing can be waste-intensive due to the screen preparation process, but there’s a silver lining: screen printing uses fewer plastics than DTF. Plus, some printing methods now use eco-friendly water-based inks instead of plastisol.
Minimum order
Need just one custom shirt? No problem with DTF transfers. Since there’s no setup time or screens, you can print single pieces or small runs without extra cost.
Screen printing requires more setup time, which means higher starting costs per design. This makes it ideal for bulk orders, but not so budget-friendly for small batches.
Production time
DTF is quick. Since it’s a digital printing process, there’s no need to burn screens or mix inks. Once you have a DTF printer and heat press, you can churn out DTF transfers at the fastest production speeds.
Screen printing works best for large batches, but setup time takes longer. However, once everything’s prepped, it’s possible to print hundreds of shirts swiftly. For large quantities, it’s an efficient choice.
Fabric type
DTF printing is like the versatile best friend of the printing industry – it works on cotton, polyester, blends, leather, and even textured fabrics. A go-to for multi-fabric printing needs.
Screen printing is great for cotton and cotton blends. However, the process can be trickier on polyester, dark fabrics, and specialty materials, often requiring extra prep and additives.
Average cost
For small runs, DTF printing is cheaper since there’s no screen preparation or high costs. But, the cost per piece doesn’t decrease much in bulk orders.
Screen printing has higher starting costs, but once those are covered, the cost per piece drops significantly. If you’re printing more than 100 shirts, screen printing is the most cost-effective choice.
So, is DTF better than screen printing? The truth is – both printing methods are fantastic, just for different needs. If you want intricate designs, color prints, and low setup costs, DTF printing excels. But if you need bold, durable designs for large orders, screen printing works like a charm.
It all comes down to your design and production goals – so choose the one that fits your style, budget, and business.
Explore other comparison articles to find the best printing technique for your business and custom designs.
DTG vs screen printing
Embroidery vs screen printing
DTF vs sublimation
Popular DTF products from our Catalog
Printify offers the biggest Catalog in the print-on-demand game, giving creators endless ways to bring their designs to life. From classic apparel to must-have accessories, our selection is packed with high-quality, DTF-friendly options.
Think cozy Gildan hoodies, soft cotton tees, trendy crewneck sweatshirts, and even sleek insulated travel mugs – ready to showcase vibrant prints with durability and style.
Sell DTF products with Printify
Starting your DTF business has never been easier. Printify makes creating, customizing, and selling high-quality DTF products simple with zero upfront investment. Follow these steps and start turning your designs into profits.
- Sign up – Register for a free Printify account and unlock access to the biggest POD catalog.
- Choose your products – Explore our Catalog, filter by “DTF printing,” and pick the perfect items.
- Apply designs – Click Start designing and use our Product Creator to upload artwork, add text, or generate AI-powered images.
- Start selling DTF goods – Integrate your store, sync products, and start selling on your favorite platforms and marketplaces.
- Let us do the rest – Focus on marketing while our Print Providers handle printing, packing, and shipping.
DTF vs screen printing: FAQ
Choosing between DTF vs screen printing? Durability, fabric options, and production time might be your main deciding factors. DTF printing is great for full-color, detailed prints on any fabric with no setup hassle. Screen printing is great for bold, long-lasting designs but requires more prep and is best for bulk orders.
Both printing methods hold up well, but in different ways. Screen printing, with its thick layers of ink, is incredibly durable and can survive endless washes. DTF prints bond tightly to fabric and resist cracking, but over time, the feel may slightly change. Proper care ensures both stay vibrant for years.
Direct-to-film (DTF) printing requires special film, powder adhesive, and a heat press, making it more technical than direct printing. The prints can have a slightly different texture compared to traditional methods. Additionally, while DTF works on all fabrics, it may not be as cost-effective for large bulk orders compared to screen printing.
DTF printing requires a process where designs are printed onto a film and heat-pressed onto fabric. Screen printing requires individual screens for each color, making it more labor-intensive. While a DTF printer can instantly create vibrant, detailed prints, screen printing is better for bold, high-volume designs. Consider exploring screen printing alternatives for the best result.
Not exactly. Screen printing has a textured, slightly raised feel due to the layers of ink, while DTF prints sit more smoothly on the fabric. Compared to other methods, direct-to-film is softer and more flexible, making it more comfortable to wear.
To sum up
We’ve explored the ins and outs of DTF vs screen printing, covering everything from quality to cost. Both methods have their strengths – DTF is versatile and detailed, while screen printing is bold and built to last. Ready to start selling? Join Printify to create and sell custom DTF products effortlessly.
