Printify vs Gelato
Compare popular print-on-demand companies for creating and selling products worldwide
eCommerce businesses choose Printify for its competitive pricing, extensive catalog of over 1,000 high-quality products from a global network of Print Providers, and reliable customer support.
Free to start – No credit card requiredHere’s what people say about us
Which print-on-demand
platform is best?
The print-on-demand business model is one of the most popular ways to make money online, but which POD platform is the right one for you?
Companies like Gelato and Printify offer unique features and products.
Here’s a breakdown of Gelato vs Printify to help you make an informed decision:
Platform costs
Up to 20% discount on all products
Includes order management with Printify Connect
Custom pricing available
Gelato Gold: $119/mo, or $1,185/yr
Custom pricing available
Print network
Business performance
Customer support
Verdict: When comparing Gelato vs Printify in terms of costs and product selection, Printify offers more value for money with the Premium subscription.
Easily switch to Printify
Scale your business and unlock the largest catalog in Print on Demand with the lowest prices.
How to choose the right print-on-demand platform
Find a print-on-demand service that works for you by comparing key details like prices, ease of use, fulfillment locations, production quality, and product selection.
Dive into our ultimate guide on Gelato and Printify to discover which of these print-on-demand platforms best suit your business goals.
1. Profitability
Discover how your profit can vary from one print-on-demand company to another.
Our t-shirt Profit Calculator compares potential earnings for Gelato vs Printify’s cheapest t-shirts when selling to Shopify customers in San Francisco.
This data was collected in September 2024, so some information may have changed since.
*Subscription plan monthly fee not included
**With the Printify Premium plan
***With Gelato+
2. Quality
Printify provides extensive transparency with its Quality Promise, ensuring high standards through three quality checks:
- Upon receiving blank products at the print location.
- Before printing custom designs.
- After printing to ensure it matches with the original design.
Printify also offers a variety of brands (e.g., Champion) and detailed product information, including fabric composition, care instructions, and size guides.
While highlighting product features like fit and fabric softness, Gelato doesn’t provide brand variety.
Verdict: Printify is the better option when it comes to quality and maximizing profits.
-
Honestly it’s the best
Honestly, everything. I love how intuitive the website is, the options that show you where your products are being printed, as well as the convenience of linking it to my Etsy shop. This is really a great resource to support folks with building their own products or small businesses.
-
I found Printify through a TikTok post…
I found Printify through a TikTok post and connected it to an Etsy store. The ease of setting up both accounts was very helpful to my creative process. Between Printify, Canva and Etsy, I have found the perfect side hustle for my creative outlet and I never even have to touch a single shirt. Who knew coming up with T-shirts could be such a potentially lucrative business?
-
Easy and efficient
It is an easy process to create designs items from the catalog. The best part is that you can set a price and it tells you how much you will profit from that item. I also enjoy that fact that you are able to publish your design straight to your shop front.
-
I added my Etsy shop to my Printify…
I added my Etsy shop to my Printify profile and already made a sale in the first 30 days. I also use Printify for my website through Shopify. I find Printify to have great and a wide range of products, an easy to use template for transferring designs and my customers are happy with the quality of my products.
-
Pretty easy to understand
Printify has been very easy to understand. There are some limited products / features, but undeniably an outstanding print on demand service.
-
Printify has been amazing
Printify has been amazing. They have built, and continue to build, an extensive network of printing providers offering a huge range of quality products at very competitive prices. They are fantastic with resolving any issues that may arise, and their customer support is always kind and accommodating. I highly recommend Printify!
-
Absolutely love these guys
Absolutely love these guys! I have been with them for last couple of years and there sure have been bumps on the way but they always come around. Business at the end of the day is to grow and evolve and provide even better services and they have surely been growing beautifully. Best wishes to the whole team and new customers 🙂
-
Printify is Very Supportive
I had some products setup on Printify and it seemed they were not syncing to my online store well. I reached out and within 2 minutes I had an easy solution that was simple to deploy. I am very appreciative for the quick support!
3. Print coverage
Let’s look at the number of fulfillment centers between Gelato vs Printify. This will affect your average shipping time, shipping costs, and your business’s carbon footprint.
Printing closer to your customers isn’t just better for buyer satisfaction – it’s also a more eco-friendly approach.
With over 130 production facilities
With 140 production hubs
Where can I sell my custom t-shirts?
Our partner network delivers around the world, fast.
Verdict: Both Printify and Gelato offer global fulfillment and local printing.
4. Product selection
The range of print-on-demand products, along with print quality, costs, shipping times, customization features, eco-friendly options, and branding, will impact your business operations and success.
26 products in other regions
Verdict: Printify’s selection of quality products is around four times bigger than Gelato’s, with way more options for eco-friendly products. Our neck labels and branding add-ons are also available without a subscription.
5. Sales channel integrations
Driving profits goes beyond quality products at competitive prices – maximizing your reach on different sales channels with comprehensive seller tools is equally important.
Although both Gelato and Printify print-on-demand platforms integrate with various sales channels, Printify stands out with comprehensive services across more platforms.
Verdict: Printify offers more integrations than Gelato with major eCommerce players like eBay. You can even launch a free Pop-Up Store with a unique store link to start selling in minutes.
Check out all the Printify integrations
See all integrations
Why switch to Printify?
- Higher profit margins
- Over 1,000 products from our global network of Print Providers
- The fastest delivery times
- Free Product Creator with AI Image Generator and advanced features to easily design custom products
Want to switch over, but you don’t have time?
Let our Team do the heavy lifting for you.
Switch to Printify today and get:
-
Listings migration
We’ll move your products over to Printify for you. Meaning you get to enjoy better prices without lifting a finger.
-
Rebates
We’ll give you money back on sales when you transfer your products to us. Speak to our Team for more details.
-
Account manager
Our Expert Team provides dedicated guidance to print-on-demand businesses.
How to start a print-on-demand business with Printify
Access all the tools you need to sell custom products in just five simple steps.
Create your account for free.
Head to the Printify Catalog and pick from over 1,000 products.
Upload an existing image, use our Shutterstock integration, or create a new design on our Product Creator.
Connect your Printify account to your preferred sales channel and publish your products.
We’ll take it from here. Every time a customer makes a purchase, we’ll print, package, and ship it while you collect the profits.
Printify changed my life
Printify is all about helping anyone, anywhere unlock their own personal freedom by making it possible to start selling top-quality merchandise online. So we love to tell stories of how we’ve helped people do just that.
Ready to start your Print on Demand business?
The information provided on this page, including any comparison of services and prices, is based on data that has been obtained from publicly accessible sources associated with the companies mentioned. The data was last updated on September 16th, 2024.
While we strive to provide accurate and timely information, we make no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability of the information contained in this article for any purpose. The use of this information and any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk. We understand that the information may change over time and therefore may become outdated or may not accurately represent the current services and prices offered by the companies mentioned.
If you are a representative of one of the companies mentioned in this article and believe any information is inaccurate or outdated, we invite you to contact us at [email protected] to provide updated information. We are committed to promptly updating any information found to be inaccurate.