CafePress pays sellers 5% of the sale price on Marketplace sales and accepts new seller accounts only from residents of the United States and US territories. The ten CafePress alternatives below give brand builders and side hustlers higher margins, wider reach, or their own branded store, depending on how they want to sell custom products.
Key takeaways
- Printify fits sellers who want their own branded store: over 2,000 products from over 70 Print Providers, a free plan, and integrations with Shopify, Etsy, and other major platforms.
- Etsy and Amazon Merch on Demand bring built-in buyer traffic. Etsy charges per listing and per sale, and Amazon accepts Merch on Demand sellers by invitation.
- Redbubble, Zazzle, Spreadshirt, TeePublic, and Society6 work like CafePress. They handle production and shipping, and they set or limit what sellers earn per sale.
- Printful and Gelato suit brands that prioritize in-house quality control or local production in 32 countries.
- Sellers who move from CafePress to a print-on-demand (POD) platform set their own retail prices and keep their customer data.
Why sellers look for CafePress alternatives
CafePress runs two selling models:
- In the CafePress Marketplace, sellers earn 5% of the sale price on every product sold.
- In their own CafePress shop, sellers add a markup on top of CafePress's base prices and keep that markup.
Three restrictions push established sellers elsewhere. CafePress accepts seller accounts only from residents of the US and its territories, pays royalties only via PayPal, and can't restore a shop once its owner closes it. Shops also stay on cafepress.com, and CafePress lists no integrations with external eCommerce platforms, so sellers can't add a second sales channel through it.
CafePress processes every payment and runs customer service, including a phone support line. The buyer relationship stays with CafePress. Sellers comparing CafePress alternatives and competitors usually check who sets the retail price, who owns the customer, and where the products can sell.
How to choose the right CafePress alternative
Four factors separate the platforms in this guide: the selling model, pricing control, the product catalog, and brand ownership. Each factor changes how much sellers earn per order and how far the business can grow.
Marketplace vs print-on-demand platform
Marketplaces handle sales and fulfillment, so sellers don't need a separate online store. Sellers upload designs, and the marketplace lists the products, takes payment, prints each item, and ships it. Marketplace discovery replaces much of the early marketing work, since shoppers already search Redbubble, Etsy, and Amazon for designs.
Print-on-demand platforms connect sellers to Print Providers for fulfillment. To create a branded online store, sellers connect a POD platform to an eCommerce platform such as Shopify or WooCommerce. Each new order then routes to production automatically.
Print on Demand also eliminates inventory management. Production starts after a customer pays, so sellers test products without upfront costs and drop designs that don't sell. Most POD platforms, including Printify, Printful, and merchOne, also set no minimum order quantities. The main difference between the two models is customer ownership: marketplaces keep the buyer, and POD platforms leave the buyer with the seller.
Profit margins and pricing control
Marketplaces set or limit seller earnings. CafePress pays 5% of the sale price on Marketplace sales, Society6 pays a fixed 5%-10% markup on its base price, and Redbubble deducts a platform fee of up to 50% from Standard accounts. Marketplace fees like these also grow when sellers raise prices, since several platforms charge extra on markups above a set level.
POD platforms let sellers set retail prices themselves. Profit equals the retail price minus the base cost, shipping costs, and any sales channel fees. At CafePress's 5% Marketplace rate, a $19.99 product pays about $1. Printify's own example below shows the same retail price earning more than $11 in a store the seller runs.
Product pricing also needs a buffer for marketplace fees when sellers list POD products on Etsy, Amazon, or other marketplaces. Sellers who control their own prices adjust them when a channel raises its fees.
Product catalog and print quality
A larger catalog lets sellers put one design on more products. The Printify Catalog lists more than 2,000 customizable products, with production options from more than 70 Print Providers. Printful produces 602 products in its own facilities. Gelato and merchOne focus on wall art, and merchOne alone offers 24 wall decoration formats, from canvas to metal prints.
Print quality depends on the product and on the production partners behind it. Sellers order samples before launching, then compare print sharpness, color, and packaging. Refund and reprint policies reduce the financial risk of a failed print. Printify's Merchant Protection covers a free reprint or refund when an order arrives damaged or with a manufacturing error, as long as sellers report it within 30 days of delivery.
Branding, store ownership, and customer data
Running their own storefront on Shopify, WooCommerce, or Squarespace gives sellers full brand control. The store collects buyer emails for email marketing, runs its own discounts, and brings repeat customers back to the brand's own store.
Branding options extend into the package itself. Printful adds the seller's branding to labels, packaging, inserts, and tracking pages. Printify Premium members get up to 33% off custom branding features. Sellers who want a recognizable brand need these touchpoints, since marketplace orders arrive in the marketplace's packaging.
Fourthwall lets sellers run their own branded storefronts, allowing creators to sell merch, memberships, and digital products from one site. Its free plan allows 50 product listings, and Fourthwall Pro costs $19 per month or $180 per year.
Best CafePress alternatives at a glance
The table compares the ten platforms by selling model, seller earnings, and cost to start.
| Platform | Type | How sellers earn | Cost to start | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Printify | POD platform | Own retail price minus base cost | Free plan; Premium from $24.99/month billed yearly | Own branded store on major platforms |
| Printful | POD platform | Own retail price minus base cost | No monthly fee to start | In-house production and branding |
| Gelato | POD platform | Own retail price minus base cost | Free plan; Gelato+ from $19.99/month billed yearly | Local production in 32 countries |
| Etsy | Marketplace with POD integration | Own retail price minus Etsy fees | $0.20 per listing, 6.5% transaction fee | Personalized products |
| Amazon Merch on Demand | Marketplace | Royalty after Amazon's costs | No upfront cost, invitation only | Apparel on Amazon |
| Redbubble | Marketplace | Markup minus 0%-50% platform fee | Free | Artists testing designs |
| Zazzle | Marketplace | Royalty of 5%-50% set by the creator | Free | Customizable gifts |
| Spreadshirt | Marketplace and shop | Fixed design price or own markup | Free | Apparel with fast production |
| TeePublic | Marketplace | Fixed earnings per product | Free | Hands-off apparel sales |
| Society6 | Marketplace | 5%-10% markup on the base price | Free, curated entry | Art prints and home decor |
Print-on-demand platforms like CafePress (sell on your own store)
These three platforms print and ship each order under the seller's brand. Sellers pick the sales channel, set retail prices, and keep their customer relationships.
Printify
Printify connects sellers to a global network of more than 70 Print Providers and more than 140 print facilities, with more than 2,000 products to customize. Sellers choose their suppliers per product and control pricing. The same t-shirts can come from a Print Provider with a lower base cost or a faster production time.
Printify integrates with 11 major eCommerce platforms and marketplaces, which gives sellers a wide set of integration options, including Shopify, Etsy, WooCommerce, Amazon, eBay, Wix, Squarespace, and TikTok Shop – currently in the US only. Sellers without a website use the free Printify Pop-Up Store, and developers connect custom stores through the Printify API.
Printify's free plan includes five stores per account and unlimited product designs. Of the premium plans, Printify Premium costs $39 per month, or $24.99 per month billed yearly, and adds up to 20% off all products and up to 33% off new products. Fulfillment costs are separate from subscription fees, and sellers pay the base cost and shipping for each order on every plan. In Printify's own example, a tee with an $8.77 fulfillment cost sold at $19.99 earns more than $11 per sale.
Sellers build products with Printify's free design tools and publish them to any connected store. Printify then handles order fulfillment through its fulfillment partners, so sellers spend their time on designs and campaigns that drive sales.
Bulk orders save up to 46% on eligible products and up to 50% on shipping once an order meets the minimum quantity, and the discounts apply automatically at checkout. Most orders ship within 2-7 business days of submission, and Printify Express Delivery targets delivery within two business days for eligible US orders.
Printful
Printful produces 602 customizable products in-house across 12 global facilities and ships to more than 190 countries. In-house production gives Printful direct quality control, and only 0.24% of its orders need reshipping.
Printful fulfills most products within 2-5 business days, and more than 97% of orders ship within five business days. Its branding options cover custom labels, packaging, inserts, and tracking pages, so customers see the seller's brand on every order.
Printful's wall art selection includes a broad range of posters, canvas, framed prints, metal prints, and acrylic options. Printful works with no order minimum and supports integrations with major eCommerce platforms such as Shopify, Etsy, Squarespace, and Amazon.
Gelato
Gelato operates a production network across 32 countries. Each order goes to one of its production partners near the buyer, which shortens delivery times and cuts international shipping costs. For sellers with buyers in many regions, this network gives Gelato an edge over Printful's 12 facilities.
Gelato's catalog includes hundreds of products, with its strongest range in wall art, posters, canvas, and calendars. The free plan connects two stores. Gelato+ costs $29.99 per month, or $19.99 per month billed annually, and adds product discounts of up to 33%.
Sellers pricing Gelato products should compare the base cost and shipping per destination. Local production lowers shipping on international orders, but Gelato relies on external partners for printing, so quality checks on samples from each region matter more.
Marketplaces like CafePress (sell to an existing audience)
Marketplaces suit sellers who want buyers before they build a brand. The platforms below handle traffic and checkout, and each one decides how much control sellers keep over price and presentation.
Etsy (with a POD integration)
Etsy combines an existing marketplace with full pricing control. Sellers set their own prices, and a POD integration handles production and shipping for every order.
Etsy charges a $0.20 listing fee, a 6.5% transaction fee on the sale price including shipping, and a 3% + $0.25 payment processing fee for US sellers. With the Printify Etsy integration, sellers publish products straight to their Etsy shop, and Printify routes each order to production.
Etsy shoppers search for gifts and custom products, which makes personalized merchandise a strong category there. Printify Personalization lets buyers add their own text and images to a product before checkout. Since June 2026, Etsy buyers also see a rendered preview of their personalized design on select apparel before they pay.
Amazon Merch on Demand
Amazon Merch on Demand puts designs on Amazon product pages, and Amazon prints, ships, and handles customer service. Selling through Amazon Merch on Demand connects creators to a large audience without any upfront cost.
Amazon accepts sellers by invitation, and new accounts start with a limited number of design slots. Royalties equal the product's offer price minus applicable tax and Amazon's costs, so sellers adjust the list price to change their earnings.
Sellers who want more control on Amazon use the Printify Amazon integration and an Amazon Professional seller account, which costs $39.99 per month. This route lets sellers set their own prices on Amazon's US marketplace, and the integration currently works with US-based Print Providers only.
Redbubble
Redbubble stays popular with independent artists who want to sell their designs with minimal setup. Sellers upload artwork, set a markup on each product, and Redbubble handles production, payment, and shipping.
Redbubble's marketplace model changed in September 2025. Standard accounts now pay a 50% platform fee on monthly earnings, Premium accounts pay 20%, and Pro accounts pay no platform fee. Standard and Premium accounts also pay a 50% fee on earnings from any markup above 20%, with total fees capped at $150 per month.
This fee structure explains where a Redbubble alternative fits. Artists who earn steady Redbubble sales on a Standard account keep half their margin, and moving best sellers to a POD platform with their own store returns that margin to them.
Zazzle
Zazzle allows buyers to customize products extensively. Shoppers edit text, colors, and images in a creator's template before ordering, making Zazzle a strong fit for invitations, gifts, and personalized merchandise.
Creators set their own royalty rate on physical products between 5% and 50%. Zazzle deducts a 5% excess royalty fee when the rate exceeds 10%, and a higher royalty increases the retail price buyers see. Zazzle also deducts a Marketing Royalty Fee of 35%-50% of gross royalties, depending on the product department, while creators who send buyers through their own Self-Promotion Links earn 35%-50% of the sale.
Spreadshirt
Spreadshirt runs a marketplace and a shop builder called Spreadshop. On the Spreadshirt Marketplace, Spreadshirt sets a fixed design price for each product type in each country, and designers can't change it. In a Spreadshop, sellers set their own prices.
SPOD, Spreadshirt's print-on-demand service, now operates as Spreadconnect. It produces and ships 95% of orders within 48 hours, offers more than 250 products, and integrates with Shopify, WooCommerce, Squarespace, and other platforms.
TeePublic
TeePublic pays artists a fixed amount for each product sold. TeePublic sets all retail prices and runs frequent sitewide sales, and artists earn a lower fixed amount on discounted orders.
TeePublic takes over production, shipping, and customer service, so sellers only need to upload designs. Earnings per t-shirt stay low compared with own-store pricing, and the platform offers no branding or storefront design options.
Society6
Society6 focuses on art prints, wall art, and home decor. It now runs a curated model, reviews every new artist application, and has removed apparel from its catalog. Society6 sets the base price of every product and adds a fixed artist markup: 10% of the base price on pillows, wall tapestries, art prints, framed art prints, and posters, and 5% on all other products.
Discounts reduce artist earnings, since Society6 calculates the payout after any customer discount. Artists who want higher margins on art prints sell the same designs through Printify, Printful, or Gelato in their own store.
CafePress vs Printify: Key differences
CafePress keeps sellers inside its marketplace and shops. Printify connects sellers to their own sales channels and leaves pricing with the seller.
| Feature | CafePress | Printify |
|---|---|---|
| Who sets the retail price | CafePress on Marketplace sales, the seller in shops | The seller |
| Seller earnings | 5% of the sale price on Marketplace sales, or own shop markup | Retail price minus base cost and shipping |
| Seller eligibility | US residents and US territories only | Open to sellers worldwide |
| Sales channels | CafePress only | 11 eCommerce platforms and marketplaces, plus the Pop-Up Store and API |
| Product selection | CafePress catalog | Over 2,000 products from over 70 Print Providers |
| Customer data | Stays with CafePress | Stays with the seller's store |
How to move your designs from CafePress to Printify
Moving to Printify takes six steps. Sellers keep their CafePress shop live until the new store takes its first orders.
- Gather your design files. Collect the original high-resolution files for every design, since Printify needs print-ready artwork.
- Create a free Printify account. The free plan covers up to five stores and unlimited designs.
- Connect your store. Link Shopify, Etsy, WooCommerce, or another eCommerce channel, or start with the Printify Pop-Up Store.
- Recreate your products. Upload designs in the Product Creator, place each design on the matching product, and pick a Print Provider based on base cost, location, and production time.
- Set retail prices and order samples. Price each product above its base cost and shipping, then order samples to check print quality before publishing.
- Redirect your audience. Point social profiles, email lists, and links to the new store, and close the CafePress shop only after customer orders move over, since CafePress can't restore a deleted shop.
Start selling with Printify
CafePress still suits US sellers who want a hands-off marketplace, but its 5% Marketplace earnings and closed sales channel cap growth. Marketplaces such as Etsy, Amazon Merch on Demand, and Redbubble add buyer traffic. POD platforms such as Printify, Printful, and Gelato let sellers set their own prices and own the customer.
For a print-on-demand business with its own branded store, Printify combines a free plan, more than 2,000 products, and integrations with the major platforms sellers already use.